Oh, in so many different ways. LOL! Let's see - miscasting, script being off, poor direction. Seriously, Lucas isn't a God. He's fallible.
The critics didn't state that those characters aren't necessary or interesting, just that for some reason or other the films and series that didn't contain them were "tighter" and "objectively speaking - better written, directed and produced" with less emphasis on special effects. The dialogue is better, sharper. The plot tighter. Look I love Star Wars, and I loved Solo, Luke and Leia - but Andor is a tighter story. I think part of the difference is that the original film and the prequels were oddly aimed at a family audience or kids.
then have they considered that maybe they don’t like Star Wars? Why not watch a different space fantasy or sci fi movie? I find that train of logic odd but I’m curious to understand why some critics or fans think that way.
Some people, myself included, enjoy critiquing the things we love. We like to see what worked and what didn't for us. It's not that complicated.
no subject
The critics didn't state that those characters aren't necessary or interesting, just that for some reason or other the films and series that didn't contain them were "tighter" and "objectively speaking - better written, directed and produced" with less emphasis on special effects. The dialogue is better, sharper. The plot tighter. Look I love Star Wars, and I loved Solo, Luke and Leia - but Andor is a tighter story. I think part of the difference is that the original film and the prequels were oddly aimed at a family audience or kids.
then have they considered that maybe they don’t like Star Wars? Why not watch a different space fantasy or sci fi movie? I find that train of logic odd but I’m curious to understand why some critics or fans think that way.
Some people, myself included, enjoy critiquing the things we love. We like to see what worked and what didn't for us. It's not that complicated.