rose_griffes (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
rose_griffes) wrote2011-12-11 07:02 am
rose_griffes) wrote2011-12-11 07:02 am
Entry tags:
Person of Interest 1.09
Person of Interest had some nice character development this week. Detective Carter got a first name, yay! And she's a mother to a young teenage son who actually seems non-bratty so far. He even knows how to smile.
(My theory about Carter growing up a city kid hasn't been stomped on yet. "Grandma" lives in the area--close enough for the grandson to stay with her sometimes.)
We knew Carter had been in Afghanistan and Iraq, but this gave us more information about her role (at least one of them): interrogator, getting information from potential terrorists. Yet we didn't see her use torture or undue coercion for this particular target; instead she used her perceptiveness and empathy in an entirely appropriate and effective way. Yusuf wasn't a hardened terrorist, just a guy trying to get by in a dangerous place.
Carter still doesn't trust Fusco enough to treat him as a friend. Hasn't lost her gift of perception in the intervening years; as much as I like Fusco, I wouldn't consider him particularly trustworthy, especially not as a fellow police officer. I wouldn't want to make him angry, but I don't blame Carter for not wanting be chums. (And yes, Fusco seems to have turned a corner, but he has a long way to go to redeem his reputation from before.)
Implications that the father of Carter's son was killed--death of a loved one being one more thing Carter has in common with Reese and Finch.
As for the Carter and Reese interactions: she wore her bullet-proof vest because he warned her! He called her by her first name! He gave her a speech about not being alone! Granted, that whole speech coming from him probably doesn't make her feel better at all, but hey... he tried.
There is one thing I'll nit-pick: Elias leaving the flowers on Carter's desk. Taking them there himself, too. I get that the show runners probably want to keep Elias in the spotlight, but really? I though he was supposed to be scary 'cause he's an old-school mafia dude, not because he's a creepy stalker (who telegraphs his evil intentions in an almost comical way).
Speaking of criticisms, my 'one thing' to complain about in the episode wasn't really mentioned at an LJ comm discussion. Plenty of other things were. The worst episode so far, what?! *sigh* We're watching a show in which a magical machine magically provides a number each week. Yeah, there's a (totally implausible) pseudo-technology explanation, but gritty realism isn't what this show is about. "Get Carter" wasn't the strongest episode, but it's not like it had lots more plotholes or silly character moments than the other episodes. And I can't decide if it's me being overly sensitive or not, but it feels like it's the episodes with the most action for female characters that get criticized the most.
And then I made the mistake of going to the TWoP forum, where the Carter (and Tariji Henson) disdain) is full-blown and unmistakeable. Why did I do that? I know better! There's a reason why I hadn't read anything there in months. Lesson (re)learned the hard way, blergh.
I had to delete a userpic in order to upload this one. *sobs* (This, by the way? The only userpic I've seen of Carter anywhere. Yeah...)
(My theory about Carter growing up a city kid hasn't been stomped on yet. "Grandma" lives in the area--close enough for the grandson to stay with her sometimes.)
We knew Carter had been in Afghanistan and Iraq, but this gave us more information about her role (at least one of them): interrogator, getting information from potential terrorists. Yet we didn't see her use torture or undue coercion for this particular target; instead she used her perceptiveness and empathy in an entirely appropriate and effective way. Yusuf wasn't a hardened terrorist, just a guy trying to get by in a dangerous place.
Carter still doesn't trust Fusco enough to treat him as a friend. Hasn't lost her gift of perception in the intervening years; as much as I like Fusco, I wouldn't consider him particularly trustworthy, especially not as a fellow police officer. I wouldn't want to make him angry, but I don't blame Carter for not wanting be chums. (And yes, Fusco seems to have turned a corner, but he has a long way to go to redeem his reputation from before.)
Implications that the father of Carter's son was killed--death of a loved one being one more thing Carter has in common with Reese and Finch.
As for the Carter and Reese interactions: she wore her bullet-proof vest because he warned her! He called her by her first name! He gave her a speech about not being alone! Granted, that whole speech coming from him probably doesn't make her feel better at all, but hey... he tried.
There is one thing I'll nit-pick: Elias leaving the flowers on Carter's desk. Taking them there himself, too. I get that the show runners probably want to keep Elias in the spotlight, but really? I though he was supposed to be scary 'cause he's an old-school mafia dude, not because he's a creepy stalker (who telegraphs his evil intentions in an almost comical way).
Speaking of criticisms, my 'one thing' to complain about in the episode wasn't really mentioned at an LJ comm discussion. Plenty of other things were. The worst episode so far, what?! *sigh* We're watching a show in which a magical machine magically provides a number each week. Yeah, there's a (totally implausible) pseudo-technology explanation, but gritty realism isn't what this show is about. "Get Carter" wasn't the strongest episode, but it's not like it had lots more plotholes or silly character moments than the other episodes. And I can't decide if it's me being overly sensitive or not, but it feels like it's the episodes with the most action for female characters that get criticized the most.
And then I made the mistake of going to the TWoP forum, where the Carter (and Tariji Henson) disdain) is full-blown and unmistakeable. Why did I do that? I know better! There's a reason why I hadn't read anything there in months. Lesson (re)learned the hard way, blergh.
I had to delete a userpic in order to upload this one. *sobs* (This, by the way? The only userpic I've seen of Carter anywhere. Yeah...)
no subject
no subject
I hope the show continues to give us glimpses of her. I don't know if they're going to keep her as an antagonist or try doing the Commissioner Gordon route eventually (since Reese + Finch = Batman), but either way, I want her to stay.
no subject
Also, if it helps, the anon meme I hang out on LOVES Carter, and more than one person has said they'd rather SHE were the star.
no subject
I think I got spoiled recently by Parks and Recreation fandom. If LJ has a Leslie Knope hater who participates in the show's fandom, I have yet to run across that person. Of course, Leslie is the heart of P&R, and comparing those two shows is like comparing
apples and orangesbrownies and buffalo wings, but yeah... a fandom in which nearly everyone openly appreciates the openly feminist and competent lead female (and the actress portraying her)? It definitely spoiled me. I temporarily forgot how not usual that kind of experience is.(And now I want to write Carter fic out of spite. Heh. Maybe after I finish writing Yuletide stuff, I'll do that.)
eta: I've wanted to write Carter fic for a while, actually. Just... I'm not sure what to write at this point. Though having a first name helps a lot.
no subject
no subject
no subject
The commenters there mostly like Reese and Finch. And some of them seem fond of Fusco as well. I'm surprised nobody there is complaining about Caviezel's whisper-talking. Or maybe they did, but I didn't look through enough pages to see it.
no subject
no subject